New Contender Overtakes Vance in Emerson’s 2028 Republican Poll

For the first time in Emerson College’s polling, Secretary of State Marco Rubio leads Vice President JD Vance among Republican primary voters for 2028, 36% to 20%. A year ago, Vance led 54% to 6%. Here’s what the poll found, how it compares with other measures, and why it may be shifting.

As of November 20, 2026. No Republican has announced a 2028 campaign.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio leads Vice President JD Vance among Republican primary voters in a new Emerson College poll, the first time Rubio has led in Emerson’s 2028 surveys. Asked to name their preferred nominee without a list of options, 36% of Republican primary voters chose Rubio and 20% chose Vance.

The shift

Emerson’s polls show how quickly the race has changed:

Emerson pollVanceRubio
November 202554%6%
February 202652%20%
May 202636%35%
November 2026 (Nov. 14–16)20%36%

Question wording differed across some surveys.

Rubio’s lead grew when voters were given a list of candidates to choose from, according to Emerson. Rubio did better among college-educated Republicans, while Vance did better among white working-class voters. President Trump, who can’t run for a third term under the Constitution, was named by 7% in both last year’s and this year’s polls.

Lower down the list, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis drew 7%, Donald Trump Jr. 6% and Tucker Carlson 5%, according to The Independent.

Other measures

  • Polling averages are closer. The RealClearPolitics average, which includes this survey, shows Rubio ahead by about 1.4 points.
  • Prediction markets still favor Vance, though by less than before.
  • Other recent polls vary. In a Reuters/Ipsos poll last week, Republicans rated Vance and Rubio about equally as potential candidates. (Our story on that poll.)

Why it may be shifting

  • The Iran war. After the midterms, Vance blamed Republicans’ losses on the war, which he reportedly opposed privately but has publicly supported. Pollster G. Elliott Morris has noted that in his polling, Rubio’s lead comes mostly from Republicans who support the war, while Vance leads among those who want it to end.
  • Rubio’s profile. Rubio spent much of the fall on diplomatic travel, though he appeared at several Trump rallies in the campaign’s final days. In Manila this week, asked about a CNN report that U.S. intelligence indicated Iran was developing plans for a possible “dirty bomb” attack in Washington, Rubio said he didn’t believe there was an “imminent threat,” adding, “we’re concerned every day about anything that threatens our country.” Trump said the U.S. was “looking into it.”
  • Criticism from the right. Conservative commentator Ben Shapiro has argued Vance can’t simply inherit Trump’s coalition, and this week said Vance is too focused on appealing to online “anti-establishment” audiences to win a national election, according to The Independent.

What hasn’t changed: Rubio has said he won’t run if Vance does, and has said he “literally will not talk about 2028 anymore.” Vance says he hasn’t decided, and sources told Axios he may not announce until late spring. (Our story on Vance’s timeline.)

Democrats

On the Democratic side, the field is spread out. Georgia Sen. Jon Ossoff edged ahead in Emerson’s poll, with former Vice President Kamala Harris, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg and California Gov. Gavin Newsom close behind. [CHECK: The Independent reported Ossoff 17%, Harris 16%, Ocasio-Cortez 15%, Buttigieg 14%, Newsom 11%, Beshear 7%; confirm against Emerson’s release.]

About the poll

Emerson surveyed 1,000 registered voters nationwide November 14–16, with a margin of error of about 3 percentage points for the full sample. The Republican primary results come from a smaller subgroup, so their margin of error is larger. Emerson conducted and funded the poll.

Sources

Spot an error? We correct mistakes openly. Read our corrections policy or tell us what we got wrong.